Halloween

With the spoof Scary Movie slashing into theaters, we asked stars for their fave fright flick:

-- MICHAEL MICHELE (ER) ''Carrie. I was afraid to go to my prom.''

-- JOHN C. REILLY (The Perfect Storm) ''Jaws. I couldn't take a bath for a long time.''

-- MATTHEW LILLARD (Love's Labour's Lost) ''Scream. Is that wrong to say something I was the killer in?''

-- JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE ('N Sync) ''When I was 4, I saw When a Stranger Calls. It was really lame but scared the crap out of me.''

-- KIMBERLY WILLIAMS (Father of the Bride) ''Heathers -- because high school is a truly terrifying time.''

-- NICK NOLTE (Trixie) ''Howdy Doody.''

-- CHRIS KIRKPATRICK ('N Sync) ''Ishtar. I sat through the whole thing and, trust me, that was scary.''


Sign up for EW.com's The 25 newsletter!

Stay in the know and get EW.com's top 5 stories, 5 days a week (sent weekday afternoons).