Dances With Wolves: Special Edition (2003)

Director-star Kevin Costner's exhaustive Western ''Dances With Wolves'' has always gotten a mixed rap. For the legions moved by its Spielbergian crescendos, just as many cynics have griped that it's too PC. For every fan pleased that it won Best Picture, there's a hardcore geek who'll never forgive it for thwarting Martin Scorsese's ''GoodFellas'' Oscar bid.

Sure, the long-winded epic will never be a classic -- a fact that Dances With Wolves: Special Edition, with an extra hour of well-crafted if unnecessary footage, can't disprove. But the set's four above-par commentaries, two revealing though repetitive production documentaries, and countless testimonials about the romantic joys of staging a buffalo hunt on the South Dakota tundra underscore the fact that ''Wolves'' is a filmmaking tour de force. And thanks largely to Aussie Dean Semler's camera work and Brit John Barry's music, both landmarks in a mostly American genre, it's also an effective, if occasionally trivial, piece of storytelling.

You Might Also Like

• DVD Commentary EW's Scott Brown names 2003's 10 best DVDs (May 20, 2003) | Scott Brown
• Video Review Rambling Rose;20,000 Leagues Under the Sea;Mary Poppins | Steve Daly
• Movie Commentary Films set underseas (1954)
• Best & Worst 2007 The 10 Best DVDs of 2007 (Mar 20, 2007) | Ken Tucker
• DVD Review The Verdict (Jun 12, 2007) | Jeff Labrecque
• All About Kirk Douglas