Hotel Paper (2003) For Michelle Branch, whose 2001 debut established her as the most sedate and asexual of the new teen stars, there'll be no getting her freak… Michelle Branch
Music Review

Hotel Paper (2003)

Michelle Branch
Reviewed by Chris Willman | Jun 27, 2003
Michelle Branch | HEY NINETEEN Branch's second album finds her kneeling at the altar of MOR pop
Image credit: Michelle Branch: Matthew Welch
HEY NINETEEN Branch's second album finds her kneeling at the altar of MOR pop
EW's GRADE
C

Details Release Date: Jun 24, 2003; Lead Performance: Michelle Branch

For Michelle Branch, whose 2001 debut established her as the most sedate and asexual of the new teen stars, there'll be no getting her freak on. Her competent, colorless follow-up, Hotel Paper, opens with ''Are You Happy Now?'' a surprising fit of power-chord pique that's unsuccessfully Avril-esque. It's the last ''rock'' song on the CD, as Branch soon reverts to wistful, acoustic-guitar-driven form, aiming to be the next Shawn Colvin (or Buckingham/Nicks, in the Sheryl Crow duet ''Love Me Like That''). There are worse aspirations for a 19-year-old, but the inescapable girlishness in her voice heightens the unlived-in quality of hackneyed, lovelorn ballads like ''Desperately,'' the least desperate-sounding song of 2003. In Branch's attempts at sounding old before her time, every lyric and hook feels shopworn. If only she could find some grown-ups who'd force her to be an adolescent: Where ARE those Svengali-ish song docs in the Matrix when you need 'em?

Originally posted Jun 27, 2003 Published in issue #716-717 Jun 27, 2003 Order article reprints