See if ''Boy Meets Boy'' is a winner or a loser
VIEWERS 1.3 million
WHAT HAPPENED Baby-faced James (aided by his train wreck of a best friend, Andra) had 10 days to pluck a soul mate from a clean-cut group of 15 men -- some of whom weren't really gay. (James found love -- or something -- in gay guy Wes.)
WHY WE'RE SPLIT There was endless joy in playing the ''Which One's the Straight Dude?'' guessing game, but many found the twist needlessly cruel: Would ''The Bachelor'' pull such a brazen stunt?
LASTING CONTRIBUTION TO THE GENRE ''Hostess'' Dani Behr made us pine for ''Bachelor'' wrangler Chris Harrison.