Ultimate Punishment: A Lawyer's Reflection on Dealing With the Death Penalty In January 2000, Illinois governor George Ryan -- disturbed by the number of death-row inmates being exonerated -- halted all executions and recruited a reform… Ultimate Punishment: A Lawyer's Reflection on Dealing With the Death Penalty In January 2000, Illinois governor George Ryan -- disturbed by the number of death-row inmates being exonerated -- halted all executions and recruited a reform… Nonfiction Farrar, Straus & Giroux
Book Review

Ultimate Punishment (Fall 2003)

EW's GRADE
C+

Details Writer: Scott Turow; Genre: Nonfiction; Publisher: Farrar, Straus & Giroux

In January 2000, Illinois governor George Ryan -- disturbed by the number of death-row inmates being exonerated -- halted all executions and recruited a reform panel that included Turow, the lawyer author of twisty legal thrillers like ''Presumed Innocent.'' Instead of churning out pathos and politics, Turow offers a fairly rote essay on well-worn topics: the shortcomings of the system, the desire for revenge. While he employs a few pro and con examples (an innocent man he defended, a serial killer who might be better off dead), he doesn't disclose his own leanings until his last, anticlimactic sentence. The stab at objectivity makes this crafty novelist seem clinical, even about Ryan's astounding decision to commute the sentences of all the state's 167 death-row inmates. Capital punishment is a topic that should heat the blood, whatever side you take. Turow's treatment barely simmers.

Originally posted Sep 26, 2003 Published in issue #730 Sep 26, 2003 Order article reprints