My Dog Skip (2009)

Here's a passage from the late Willie Morris' 1995 memoir, ''My Dog Skip'': ''Cruising through the fringes of town, I would spot a group of old men standing around up the road. I would get Skip to prop himself against the steering wheel... while I crouched out of sight under the dashboard.... As we drove by the Blue Front Café, I could hear one of the men shout: 'Look at that ol' dog drivin' a car!'''

The dry, humane grace of that scene is exactly what doesn't make it into director Jay Russell's big-screen adaptation of My Dog Skip. Instead, we get a serviceable time-passer for kids, grandparents, and poochophiles that feints toward the toughness of ''To Kill a Mockingbird'' but stays well within Hallmark-homily territory.

As young Willie, ''Malcolm in the Middle'''s Frankie Muniz looks uncomfortable without any irony to latch on to, and a subplot about the black denizens of WWII-era Yazoo, Miss., is dropped before it can threaten to develop an edge. Worst of all, the Jack Russell playing Skip is allowed to mug à la ''Frasier'''s Eddie instead of behaving like an actual canine. Look at that ol' dog stealin' a movie!

You Might Also Like

• Book Review My Dog Skip | Gene Lyons
• Video Review My Dog Skip | Scott Brown
• Movie Review My Dog Skip (2000) | Ty Burr
• Kids' Corner Extra Beagle mania! Great movies starring dogs | Chris Nashawaty
• Features Cry Hard 2 The Readers Strike Back (1988) | Sumeet Bal, Marc Bernardin, Monica Mehta, Joshua Rich, Erin Richter, Michael Sauter, Missy Schwartz, Nancy Sidewater
• EW's New Issue Why YOU say ''My Dog Skip'' is a top tearjerker (2000)