Mulan (2004) How do you make the legend of Mulan (Ming-Na), a Chinese daughter who takes her aging father's place in battle, funny? Turns out you don't,…
Movie on DVD Review

Mulan (2004)

EW's GRADE
B+

Details Release Date: Oct 26, 2004; DVD Release Date: Oct 26, 2004; Movie Rated: G; Genres: Action/Adventure, Animation, Kids and Family; With: Ming-Na and Eddie Murphy

How do you make the legend of Mulan (Ming-Na), a Chinese daughter who takes her aging father's place in battle, funny? Turns out you don't, really. Not even if you've got Eddie Murphy's first attempt at playing an animated sidekick, Mulan's ''demoted''ancestor/dragon companion, Mushu. Luckily, Mulan's girl-power message continuously (and commendably) rings true.

EXTRAS The Lord of the Rings-size treatment — more than 15 featurettes on story, design, production, and music — covers the filmmakers' five-year process, their struggle to find Mulan's feminist yet father-honoring tone, and their praise of the crew member most responsible for making the film feel ''particularly Chinese.''Commentary from the directors and producer acknowledges that female animators drooled over shirtless Captain Shang — and that no one knows why his Imperial army shrunk by roughly 90 percent between the training montage and the first bout with the big bad Hun 12 minutes later. A cut Mushu song proves forgettable, while a cheesy, low-budget Jackie Chan music video (slo-mo! multiple exposures!) is anything but.

Originally posted Oct 29, 2004 Published in issue #790 Oct 29, 2004 Order article reprints