Late-night chatter got a little quieter on Thursday when CNBC announced that it was canceling Charles Grodin's show after three and a half years (effective Monday). The network says that Grodin's trademark diatribes on social issues didn't fit between Brian Williams' and Geraldo Rivera's news shows. "Charles Grodin's program was headed in a different editorial direction than the rest of CNBC's prime time," says CNBC spokesman George Jamison. "It was a mutual decision to go ahead and end the show."

Ratings were not the issue, says Jamison. True, Grodin's 11 p.m. show had less than half the viewers of CNBC's prime-time programs. (He averaged 227,000 households in May, versus 482,000 households for CNBC's prime-time shows.) On the other hand, Grodin's ratings had nearly doubled from a year ago.

According to Entertainment Weekly TV editor Jamie Bufalino, the cancellation is probably related to Grodin's penchant for breaking telegenic conventions: He would open each show with a rant against such favorite targets as O.J. Simpson and Howard Stern and would often pause in the middle of lecturing the audience to stare off-camera in eerie silence. "Grodin made it work for awhile because of his eccentricity if nothing else," says Bufalino. "But cable television is upping the ante. You can't have just a talking head anymore, no matter how bizarre that head is."


Sign up for EW.com's What to Watch Newsletter!

What to watch on TV. Hear what's on tap for the night ahead and get witty, morning after recaps of top shows (sent weekday mornings).