Stars name their first celeb crush | cruz_l
SISTER LOVE Not that there's anything wrong with Cruz
Penelope Cruz: Denis Fisher/London Features

DAVID SPADE (''Just Shoot Me'') ''My first: Farrah, of course. My most recent: one of the Backstreet Boys.''

JENNA LEWIS (''Survivor'') ''MacGyver. Not only is Richard Dean Anderson attractive, he could make a bomb out of a toothpick.''

BRUCE VILANCH (''Hollywood Squares'') ''Sandra Dee, but that was before I discovered Tab Hunter.''

JENNY McCARTHY ''Chad Lowe. How dorky am I?''

TOM HANKS ''Oh landy. Sophia Loren. Come on, who else is there?''

HEAVY D ''Pam Grier. She could kick my ass, but she was hot.''

MING-NA (''ER'') ''Shaun Cassidy and The Fonz. Looking back, I don't know what I was thinking.''

HEATHER GRAHAM ''Dustin Hoffman in 'Tootsie.' He was a really good actor.''

PENÉLOPE CRUZ (''All the Pretty Horses'') ''Marilyn Monroe and Shirley MacLaine. I'm not a lesbian, but...you can feel attraction in so many ways.''

KATHY GRIFFIN ''Peter Frampton. I loved his skinny, badass bare chest on 'Frampton Comes Alive!'''

MICHAEL CAINE ''Shirley Temple. At least I was the same age as her at the time -- it wasn't pedophilia.''

COURTNEY LOVE ''Judd Nelson from 'The Breakfast Club.'''

KATE HUDSON (''Almost Famous'') ''Corey Haim or Fred Savage in 'The Wonder Years.'''

JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE ''Sam from 'Who's the Boss?' [Alyssa Milano]. She was hot and could play sports, too.''

JEREMY PIVEN (''The Family Man'') ''Brooke Shields -- it was her golden locks, full lips, olive skin, and firm buttocks.''

BROOKE SHIELDS ''David Cassidy -- the way he pronounced 'Aaaa Think I Love You.'''

ALAN RACHINS (''Dharma & Greg'') ''Jean Simmons. The actress from [1949's] 'The Blue Lagoon,' not the guy from Kiss.''

CARMEN ELECTRA ''Paul Stanley from Kiss. Something about that [eye] star was very sexy.''

PHILIP SEYMOUR HOFFMAN (''State and Main'') ''Debra Winger. I was 13 years old and...I cried for a week after 'Terms of Endearment.' I'm not even kidding.''

MATTHEW LILLARD (''Scooby-Doo'') ''Kathleen Turner, who later became my mom in a movie [1994's 'Serial Mom']—so that is kind of gross.''

DIANE LANE (''The Perfect Storm'') ''John Travolta. He ruled a 15 year span of puberty for me and a generation of women.''

KELLY PRESTON ''I didn't have any until John [Travolta]. And I got him. Pretty good, eh?''


Sign up for EW.com's The 25 newsletter!

Stay in the know and get EW.com's top 5 stories, 5 days a week (sent weekday afternoons).