Home
KATHARINE MCPHEE (Season 5)
Even the folks who left the biggest impressions tonight did so mostly because they reminded me of superior counterparts from the Greensboro, N.C., tryouts....I'm sorry, but the only way I could possibly envision Katharine McPhee's melismatic ''God Bless the Child'' taking her to the final 12 would be to extinguish the smoldering memory of Paris Bennett's ''Take Five,'' which I heard only 24 hours ago — and let me tell you, that just ain't happening, people. —Michael Slezak, Jan. 26, 2006
Next Photo
