Briana Davis, ''The Phantom of the Opera'' (Season 4)
The goth chick who sang ''Phantom of the Opera'' hit every single note, and then admitted to never having taken singing lessons. To which Paula, in a rare moment of lucidity, responded: ''I wouldn't even take vocal lessons.'' Gave me chills all up and down my spine. —denny

Briana Davis's audition: Watch it on YouTube