Brokeback Mountain (2005)

Beautifully shot, well scripted, well acted, but I had ZERO emotional connection with the leads. Ang Lee did the whole forbidden love thing much better in Crouching Tiger. If this was a ''straight'' love story, it would have died a quick death. — Scott

I was so excited to see the movie that I bought the book while in London and read it first. It was awful. I thought, The movie HAS to be good — everyone says it is, right? Hated it. The scenery was beautiful. Seeing Jake and Heath's bare bums: beautiful. That's all the good I can say. — Jennifer

I felt absolutely nothing at the end of Brokeback except for embarrassment that Heath Ledger's old-age makeup was so awful. — Lauren