This year's Emmy nominations were no laughing matter! Not when you consider the number of great sitcoms and hilarious performances that got overlooked. But don't fret: Voters in the first annual EWwy Awards turned the Emmys on their heads! Four nominees in every category were selected from your passionate rants on our PopWatch message boards, then EW's Gillian Flynn and Ken Tucker rounded out each list with a ''critic's choice'' selection. Voting closed at noon Pacific time on Sept. 17. Click through the contenders in the comedy divisions right now (along with reader tributes to each nominee), as well as our drama categories, then check back at EW.com on Sept. 19 to see who takes home coveted Golden Ewe statuettes!