Jessica Sanchez – ''Love You I Do'' by Jennifer Hudson
Jessica burst onto the live Idol stage with a performance of ''Love You I Do'' from Dreamgirls that was not only sassy and energetic, but displayed her vocal prowess.
Phillip Phillips – ''In the Air Tonight'' by Phil Collins
Phillips' first live performance on the Idol stage was compelling and established him as a contender, but could not match Jessica's energy and peerless vocal chops.

Winner: Jessica