At last week's Idol season premiere screening in L.A., Minaj wore a demure (for her) color block body con dress. Carey chose a red strapless maxi dress when she arrived for the Hollywood audition rounds in December.
Image Credit: Imeh Akpanudosen/Getty Images; Frank Micelotta/Fox
''American Idol'' judges' rivalry extends to their fashion choices -- and you get to proclaim the verdict!