Minaj's neon suit matched the step and repeat at the Macy's launch of her Pink Friday perfume last fall. In 2009, Carey's outfit matched the black carpet at the Macy's launch of Forever.
Who wore it better?
Image Credit: Gary Gershoff/WireImage; Kevin Mazur/WireImage
Photo 2 of 10
''American Idol'' judges' rivalry extends to their fashion choices -- and you get to proclaim the verdict!
In partnership with CNN
Copyright © 2013 Entertainment Weekly Inc. All rights reserved.