This gauzy photo shows Emily (Shay Mitchell, far right) at the youngest we've ever seen her — in a flashback before we originally met the swim-extraordinaire gal in Pretty Little Liars' June 2010 series debut. Her look in those early days is, in a word, safe. ''Viewers are so funny,'' says PLL costume designer Mandi Line, ''if she's not in bright colors for flashbacks, they'll be like, that's not Old Emily! They get really hooked on what they remember. They love those flashbacks.''