Would-be front-runners who tripped up on wonky song choices, fashion missteps, and vocal deficiencies
See what David Cook, Kelly Clarkson, Chris Daughtry, and more ''Idol'' alums have in the works
Like Simon says, song choice can make or break any 'Idol'; see just how true that can be!
See the favorites and unexpected underdogs you put in the ''American Idol'' Audition Hall of Fame
With the show's return next week, here are our dirty dozen of tunes we never want to hear on ''Idol'' again
Here are YOUR suggestions on how to make the next ''Idol'' season better
Reinventing Mariah, his hairdo, and more: Relive the ups and downs of the season 7 winner
The magic of ''Imagine,'' the hubbub over his dad, and more: Relive the ups and downs of the season 7 runner-up
Get edgier, Jordin! Trash the stupid hats, Blake! From styling to song choice, we offer suggestions to the finalists
What ever happened to Trenyce? Mario Vazquez? We catch up with a few of your favorites
On the EW.com PopWatch blog, we asked you which stars would make the best mentors -- here are your suggestions
In partnership with CNN
Copyright © 2014 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.